StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Why states obey the laws of war - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Our world has become more organized and civilized, especially from the last century, mainly because countries themselves and importantly in coordination with other countries has formulated a set of laws and has become part of various international treaties. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
Why states obey the laws of war
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Why states obey the laws of war"

Download file to see previous pages

These laws and treaties have actualized an environment of self-regulations, so that the countries obeying it, have maximally minimized aggressive overtures against other countries as well as their own citizens. However, that is not the case all the time, as certain countries without obeying the international laws have acted or are acting aggressively and unilaterally. This gross violation of international laws by countries has raised doubts about the validity and efficacy of these laws. Even amidst these disobeying of laws, countries tend to obey laws due to certain reasons.

States obey the laws and the related treaties and conventions due to mix of certain valid reasons, which mainly borders on self-interest and need for self-legitimacy, and also minimally due to coercion. Self interest constitutes various factors and one key factor is the want of the country to create a positive identity for itself. Participation in the transnational legal process and obeying all the laws helps “constitute the identity of the state as the one that obeys the law”. (Coleman).

Importantly, they does not want to acquire the tag or reputation of a law breaker or a rogue nation, and thereby standing isolated and facing a barrage of debilitating sanctions. That is, if a nation continues to disobey the laws and thereby acts in a detrimental way against particular nations as well as global community on the whole, certain nations and also overseeing body like United Nations will impose economic sanctions, trade, food and other essential commodities embargoes, etc. These punitive actions will negatively impact the nation as well as its people.

In order to avoid these scenarios, nations will tend to obey the laws. As another form of self interest, nations will obey laws to make or demand other nations to do the same. States will tend to obey laws whose underpinning political rational is clear and which they agree with, especially the laws relating to territorial integrity and inviolability of borders.(King 2005). Once obeying of law based on self-interest is done, then legitimacy will automatically fall into place. That is, states will always want legitimacy to its words and actions, and to get that they have to obey the laws.

If they want other countries to be legitmate, they have to create and obey laws appropriately. This was validated by Professor Frank who states that legitimacy means that quality of law must derive from a perception, to those to whom it is addressed, that law has come into being in accordance with right process. (Rashid 2004). Even coercion and the resultant obeying of the law is also an extension of self-interest. When a state is coerced to obey laws through armed force or other means, they will accept it mainly from self-interest perspective.

In certain cases, nations will obey laws as a form of nonconsensual coercion, but would like to exhibit as self-interest. The bottom line is, all states will want to live in peace, prosperity and in good coordination with other states and for that they will obey the international laws. When viewed from another perspective, certain States although generally act in accordance to the law, they do not always obey it. This happens mainly in the case of unilateral actions and importantly due to mis-interpretation of the laws according to their self-interests.

Also, when certain States feel as they were not part of specific law making process, they are not obligated to follow that law. When states take unilateral actions to fulfil and pursue their self-interests, imperialistic ambitions, etc, they disobey and undermine the international laws. Although, they may be part of the law making process and could have acted in accordance with those laws most of the time, they could disobey. As an

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Why states obey the laws of war Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1411804-why-states-obey-the-laws-of-war-
(Why States Obey the Laws of War Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1411804-why-states-obey-the-laws-of-war-.
“Why States Obey the Laws of War Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1411804-why-states-obey-the-laws-of-war-.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Why states obey the laws of war

The Flaws in the Concept of Knighthood

Name Tutor Course College Date The flaws in the concept of Knighthood The concept of knighthood was a strategy to the military which was mainly used to supply men who were to fight the king's war.... This is one of the chivalric values that he is supposed to obey.... Chivalry codes states that knight is a brave and fearless warrior who must be ready to die while protecting his people....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Positivism and the Tradition of Austin

In other words, the law is on the books, so the citizens must obey, yet the laws are silly, so it also the citizen's duty to attempt to get the law changed by censure.... In doing so, he critiqued the legal philosophies of Bentham and Austin, stating that they were naive, especially Austin, in stating that laws are based upon coercion and just the fact that these laws are in existence, without taking into account the standards by which these laws should be based....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Political Obligation - Why Should We Obey the Law

The individual agrees to obey the laws and the State, in the form of the government, police force, justice system etc.... The question of why the individual should obey the law is a central dilemma of any society.... Most individuals have impulses that, if succumbed to, would cause them to break the law and yet most people, most of the time tend to obey the law even when the likelihood of being caught is small.... hellip; This paper will consider both why we should obey the la and why, much of the time, we do obey the law....
6 Pages (1500 words) Thesis

Illegal Migration and Middle East Profiling

hellip; The rest are however of the opinion that outlawing illegal migration and employing racial profiling are a necessary evil Illegal immigrants areundocumented immigrantsor aliens in the United states who enter the borders of United states without government permission or those who stay beyond the termination date of a visa....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Jurisprudential Analysis of Charles Dickens The Great Expectation

According to John Locke, the government is necessary so as to preserve natural law and avoid a state of nature where every individual is in a state of war with other individuals.... This paper seeks to answer these abstract questions, through a jurisprudential analysis of Charles Dickens' book, "The Great expectations"....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Boosting Morale of an Athletic Team

In the studies by Solomon Asch's, conformity demonstrates that a substantial people's number will conform under a confrontation by a group with an opinion… Individuals' behavior is quite different in the presence of other individuals.... Behavior that the display may not occur normally is evoked via beliefs that are altered due to their situation socially An example is that, in recent news observation of rioting due to political decision disapproval has occurred in different countries (Wren, 1999)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Socrates and His Submission to Law

In another occasion, the Crito, Socrates stated that it was of importance to comply to the laws of Athens it is very clear that he is All through the book Socrates proves his respect for the law as well as his deep desire to continue studying philosophy.... This paper will discuss why Socrates submitted to the law despite being innocent and it will seek to prove that Socrates love for his religion was far above his willingness to cooperate with the laws of Athens, and that he also respected the laws very much....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Law: Civil Disobedience

This work called "Law: Civil Disobedience'" describes an analysis of the limits of citizens' obligation to obey the law, the rule of law.... There are instances when citizens in a democratic society violate their obligation to obey the rule of law.... An analysis of the limits of citizens' obligation to obey the law is imperative to understand civil disobedience in western legal tradition.... His central concern was to question American's engagement in war and slavery, which were constructs of unjust laws according to him....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us