StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Legal systems and skills - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
R (Quintavalle) v Secretary of State for Health [2003] UKHL 13 Name: Institution: Introduction R (Quintavalle) v Secretary of State for Health [2003] UKHL is a case example of courts purposively approaching the interpretation of legislation. The case was concerned with whether or not licensing of live human embryo creation through cell nuclear replacement (CNR) was outlawed in 1990’s HFE Act…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Legal systems and skills
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Legal systems and skills"

Download file to see previous pages

The House of Lords (HL) believed that the Act’s purpose was meant to protect human embryos made externally, rather than the manner in which the embryo formed. They ruled that parliament did not intend any distinguishing between CNR and fertilization created embryos, especially since CNR at the time was thought impossible. The HL decided that parliament did not mean to leave CNR formed embryos unregulated; therefore, the Act applied. For this reason, the Court opined that CNR was legal. Summarize the facts and legal arguments in this case Bruno Quintavalle undertook litigation on behalf of a claimant, Pro-life Alliance, in order to seek a declaration that CNR created human embryos were not created via fertilization.

He claimed that embryos from CNR were not within an embryo’s definition for the Act’s purpose. The Secretary of State, as the defendant, argued that Section 1(1) of the HFE Act should be purposively interpreted so that the fundamental subject the Act referred to was a live human embryo, rather than the manner in which the embryo was created1. The sub-section, in this case, would be read with the words, defining the embryo was a live human embryo where fertilization has been completed, in the event that the embryo was produced by fertilization2.

Parliament’s clear intention, thus, was the control of human reproduction through licensing or prohibition using the HFE Act. Crane J., despite acknowledging that purposive interpretation was a powerful argument, he held that this interpretation would allow an impermissible extension and re-writing of the definition3. Crane J.’s decision, however, was appealed successfully by the Secretary of State for Health with Lord Phillips MR, who gave the Court of Appeal’s main judgment, contended that parliament’s legislation was mostly related to how embryos were treated.

Therefore, although the legislation expressly contemplated embryos as being created through fertilization, the question, fundamentally, was whether the CRN produced embryos did fall into a similar category or genus as fertilization-produced embryos. Considering that both embryo types were fundamentally identical in their ability to develop into adults of their relevant species, the two types of embryos were clearly held as being in the same genus4. As far as legislative policy was concerned, Lord Phillips held that the intention of parliament was in order to control the use and creation of human cells; therefore, it was essential that those embryos created through CNR should be considered as part of the regulatory scheme that the Act created.

In addition, the Master of the Rolls contended that no countervailing considerations existed that could militate against a purposive approach to the case. Even though, some of the provisions in the legislation were not applicable to CNR created embryos, it did not remove the importance of enhancing effect of parliament’s intention. These inconsistencies were not as serious because, in various cases, they are remediable by HFE Act regulations, and in some different cases, they do not have much practical significance that those embryos produced through CNR should undergo exclusion from the HFE Act.

After the Appeals Court, denied authorization of appealing against this judgment, the petitioners were still able to petition the HL successfully5. However, following Pro-life

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Legal systems and skills Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words”, n.d.)
Legal systems and skills Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1480480-legal-systems-and-skills
(Legal Systems and Skills Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words)
Legal Systems and Skills Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1480480-legal-systems-and-skills.
“Legal Systems and Skills Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1480480-legal-systems-and-skills.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Legal systems and skills

Legal skills foundation/english legal system

If judges use a purposive approach, they are engaging in an essentially legislative function, which is a breach of the doctrine of the separation of powers. In the British legal tradition, it is the duty of courts to interpret the plain meaning of definite, black letter statutory language.... Harassment & DiscriminationSexual or racial harassment have no separate legal home and have been dependent upon a civil action in the form of direct discrimination....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Assessing the Different Sources of the Law in England and Wales

This paper declares that Law in England and Wales in quite rich in attaining its content from various sources.... There are four commonly known sources of law in England and Wales out of which, two are internal sources while the other two are external sources.... nbsp;… According to the study the internal sources existent in England and Wales are twofold and can be named as legislation or acts of parliament (Statute Law) and the decisions of the courts or judges (Common law)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Origin and Concepts of Laws in England and Wales

Common law can be defined as legal precedent that is made by judges sitting in a court.... Common law is constantly changing because the interpretation and knowledge of legal precedent and application of common sense as pertains to individual's cases and available facts is bound to change (Antoine 2008, P....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

English Legal System and Skills

English Legal System and skills Case I: Rose Rose may have criminal responsibility if it can be proven that she suspected the money she kept for her brother was acquired through criminal means.... According to the section 93A(1)(a) of the criminal justice act 1988, identifies that a person will be considered to have aided a… The second part outlines that this will be so if the first person knew or suspected that the second person had acquired the same money by criminal means....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Legal System and Skills

The appeal was referred by CCRC on the basis that the decision in Morgan Smith had changed the legal position.... Having had an unhappy marriage, this couple had separated on December 1978.... Mrs.... James then left their matrimonial home where she formed another relationship with Nigel Dutfield....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Crime Prevention and Measures to Safeguard Public Safety

and his decision was that the plaintiff be compensated for 3, 500 pounds for damages where 1, 400 is interest accrued and in addition expenses of the proceedings.... Subsequently, he dismissed the counterclaims by the defendants. 3.... The main… ason why the defendant was in financial difficulty is because first the agreed amount of 20, 000 pound was too low to allow him operate reasonably at profit and secondly the plaintiff did not supervise his workmanship adequately. 4....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

English Legal System and Skills

Even though juries may offer a verdict that is not consistent with evidence or legal principles, the jury should be retained because English legal system and skills May 7, English legal system and skills One of the objectives of law is to ensure law and order through determining disputes.... The process can be formal, involving a judicial officer and legal counsel or can be… A jury trial involves evaluation by a section of the public, but with guidance of a judge on matters of law....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

English Legal Systems and Skills

This report "English legal systems and skills" focuses on the case that was an allegation that the claimant had sexually assaulted a fifteen-year-old schoolboy who was undergoing a short period of work experience at the school where the claimant had been newly employed as music assistance.... nbsp;… The legal issue to be proved at first instance was whether there was any form of sexual contact between the claimant and the boy.... nbsp; The initial grounds of appeal by the appellant were that he was denied his right to legal representation1 by the school board which amounted to gross violation of his rights under the European Convention on Human Rights that among other rights provide for a right to a legal representation2....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us