StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Law and Intellectual Property Memorandum - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Law and Intellectual Property Memorandum" discusses liability in the case of Mr. Ben Kenobi’s pictures being used by Jedi on a website hosted by Emperor, and competitors gaining access to Jedi’s secret formula on Empire’s data servers…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.5% of users find it useful
Law and Intellectual Property Memorandum
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Law and Intellectual Property Memorandum"

Law and Intellectual Property Memorandum RE: Possible liability in the case of Mr. Ben Kenobi’s pictures being used by Jedi on a website hosted by Emperor, and competitors gaining access to Jedi’s secret formula on Empire’s data servers. Question Presented What is the possible liability in the case of Jedi using Mr. Kenobi’s pictures on a website hosted by Emperor, when Jedi purchased the pictures in good faith from a third party and Mr. Kenobi can prove that the pictures are his? Moreover, what is the possible liability in the case of Jedi’s competitors obtaining Jedi’s secret formula through Empire’s data servers, since Emperor assured Jedi that the sensitivity of the data will be taken care of? Brief Answer Yes, Mr. Kenobi is entitled to a fair royalty from Jedi and he also could seek a court injunction requiring his pictures to be removed from Jedi’s website until the royalty is received. Since i) Mr. Kenobi can prove that the pictures are his and ii) Jedi did digitally copy the pictures intentionally by deliberately uploading them onto Emperor’s server, this constitutes primary infringement. No, Mr. Kenobi is not entitled to any damages or royalties from Emperor. Since Empire is only providing a hosting service for Jedi’s website, Emperor did not directly nor intentionally copy the pictures, it simply received a copy of the pictures from Jedi through the rendering of a hosting service. This only constitutes secondary infringement and there was no intent to copy. Probably, Empire is liable to Jedi for the fair market value of the secret formula, unless specific damages had been outlined in the contract between them. Since Empire did not copy the information directly, it does not constitute primary infringement. Although it did inadvertently provide the means for others to do so, Empire did not have any intent of copying, therefore it does not constitute secondary infringement either. However, the data was explicitly labeled as confidential by Jedi and Empire was negligent in protecting the confidentiality of the data. Yes, Jedi is entitled to a fair royalty from its competitors for use of their unregistered design right and could also seek a court injunction to not only prevent the further illegal use of their secret formula, but also have all products where their secret formula was illegally used recalled until the royalty is received. Statement of Facts This office is considering possible liability between Jedi, Emperor and Mr. Kenobi. Jedi has posted on its website (hosted by Empire) pictures reputed to belong to Mr. Kenobi. Despite Mr. Kenobi having threatened to sue both Jedi and Empire unless the pictures are removed, the pictures have remained on the website. This office is also considering possible liability between Emperor and Jedi. Although Jedi’s CEO had specified to Empire’s CEO that their data was sensitive, Mr. Maul and his team have incorrectly configured security permissions, resulting in 27 other Empire customers gaining access to data in Jedi’s account, including Jedi’s secret formula for their Light Saber Ultra-Pro shoes. This formula has been published shortly after on over 5,000 websites, and Jedi’s competitors have already begun manufacturing shoes using Jedi’s secret formula. Discussion It is unlikely that Mr. Kenobi will be awarded any damages, royalties or other compensation from Empire. Indeed, in order for such an award to be made, it must be established that i) Mr. Kenobi is the rightful owner of the rights to the pictures and that ii) the pictures have been copied by Empire without Mr. Kenobi’s permission or consent. While it is claimed that Mr. Kenobi can prove that the pictures are his, since Empire has also been involved in an involuntary breach of confidentiality regarding sensitive data belonging to Jedi (who uploaded the pictures), this raises the question of the legitimacy of Mr. Kenobi’s claim: are the pictures truly the property of Mr. Kenobi or is he fraudulently claiming the pictures to be his after illegally obtaining them from Jedi’s website hosted by Empire. This legal opinion is based on the assumption that the pictures are the legitimate property of Mr. Kenobi. Although the pictures have been copied onto Empire’s data servers by Jedi, the Electronic Commerce (EC Directive) Regulations 2002 reg 17 would hold Empire harmless and immune to prosecution provided that Empire i) did not instigate or request the copying of the pictures, ii) did not select to whom the pictures would be sent, iii) did not select or edit the contents of the picture, iv) only copied the pictures for the process of transferring them and v) did not retain the copy of the pictures for longer than is necessary for transferring them. Since the pictures were uploaded by Jedi onto Empire’s data servers and that Empire served solely in the capacity of provider of hosting services, Empire will not be liable to Mr. Kenobi. It is very likely that Mr. Kenobi will be awarded a fair royalty from Jedi or that he will successfully obtain a court injunction forcing the removal of the pictures from Jedi’s website. Indeed, all that would need to be established is the ownership of the pictures (see above) and the act of copying, and it cannot be refuted that Jedi copied Mr. Kenobi’s pictures as those pictures are still on Jedi’s website. Although Jedi purchased the pictures from a third party, it cannot be assumed that any license for commercial use was implied or that the third party even had the right to sell Mr. Kenobi’s pictures. It is very likely that Jedi will be awarded fair market value of their secret formula from Empire. Indeed, the damages sustained by Jedi through the negligence of Empire are irrefutable, since Jedi’s competitors have not only obtained Jedi’s secret formula, but are using it in their own products. Despite Jedi’s CEO having informed Empire’s CEO of the sensitive nature of the data uploaded to Empire’s data servers, Mr. Maul and his team have improperly configured security permissions on Empire’s data centers. It is assumed that Mr. Maul and his team are employees or contractors acting under the influence or control of Empire, therefore Empire itself has been negligent in exerting due diligence to keep Jedi’s secret formula confidential. If the service contract between Jedi and Empire specify damages for breach of confidentiality, then those damages will take preeminence. If not, although Jedi’s competitors have gladly accepted Jedi’s secret formula at no cost, at what cost would they have been willing to purchase Jedi’s secret formula? This should be the amount of the award. It is also very likely that Jedi will be successful in enforcing it’s unregistered design right, because all that is required is for Jedi to prove that i) it owns the rights to the secret formula and that ii) it’s competitors copied it. Since it can be assumed that i) Jedi can provide sufficient evidence that it developed the secret formula and therefore owns it and that ii) it is obvious that Jedi’s competitors have copied Jedi’s secret formula in their products, Jedi will then be able, at its discretion, to require payment of a fair royalty from all competitors who have used the secret formula, or alternatively obtain an injunction not only preventing the further illegal use of their secret formula, but also forcing the recall of all competitor products in which its secret formula has been used. Although the users and websites who originally gained access to and published Jedi’s secret formula have been the agents which have ultimately allowed Jedi’s competitors to obtain Jedi’s secret formula, publishing a secret formula does not constitute infringement of an unregistered design right unless the formula itself has been copyrighted or all rights have been reserved: it is the usage of the secret formula which constitutes primary infringement. It should be noted that a judgment ordering the payment of a fair royalty from Jedi’s competitors and a judgment ordering Empire to pay fair market value to Jedi for the secret formula are mutually exclusive, since either settlement would constitute full restitution. References The Electronic Commerce (EC Directive) Regulations 2002 SI 2002/2013 reg 17. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Law and Intellectual Property Memorandum Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1576295-legal-memo-see-assignment-criteria-uk-civil-law-course
(Law and Intellectual Property Memorandum Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 1)
https://studentshare.org/law/1576295-legal-memo-see-assignment-criteria-uk-civil-law-course.
“Law and Intellectual Property Memorandum Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1576295-legal-memo-see-assignment-criteria-uk-civil-law-course.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Law and Intellectual Property Memorandum

A Certain Shift in the Requirements for Originality of Author Works and Copyrights

Likewise, In Spain Article 1 of the Real Decreto Legislativo 1/1996, de 12 de abril, which is Spain's main copyright law states that "The intellectual property of a literary, artistic or scientific work is entitled to its author for the sole fact of its creation.... The law towards protection of software copyrights is statutory.... In the UAE, Federal law No....
4 Pages (1000 words) Coursework

Doing Foreign Business in China

These areas include taxation, import procedures, currency dealings, agency distribution arrangements, protection of intellectual property and property rights.... Because of this risk, Definitely Maybe must acquaint itself with the type of law and dispute-settlement procedure which the company will apply.... Business law International In order to transact business more successfully in China, a foreign company investing in China should consider forming a subsidiary in China....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Plagiarism:a critique of the rapacious perpetual copyrights

Whatever trademark violations attached to the artistic appropriation of intellectual property, to tiptoe away the common signs into some towering irrelevance seems far worse.... As dubious as the word “copyright” may seem, going by the numerous conceptions from the varied academic quotas, it remains a tightly knitted guard to the encroachment in the sphere of “intellectual property.... It only serves intellectual curiosity to question the construction of contemporary copyright, which is taken as a law, universally recognized with moral absoluteness akin to the biblical right to life, or as the inherent natural law of gravity (Drahos, 1998, p....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Legal and Ethical Issues on Classified Information

Classified information Author Institution Legal and Ethical Issues on Classified Information Introduction The ethical and legal issues associated with the release of classified information for media sensational, safeguarding, classifying and declassifying the information on national security.... hellip; The democratic principles in US require that Americans be informed on government activities....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Clive's Response to Sandeep

The offer by Sandeep qualifies as a social engineering attack on the employee of another organization to acquire confidential & commercially sensitive information of that organization which may be including their intellectual property rights (IPR).... Secondly, if the organization (Ishimura in this case study) files a lawsuit against the company indulging into the social engineering activity (Tomoko in this case study) as per the clauses against breach of confidentiality/trade secrets/intellectual property Rights as applicable in the legal system of the country, the global reputation of Tomoko would be at a serious stake whereby damages can be irreparable....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

LEGAL FORMALITIES

The discussion below usually covers ent rules and policies, laws, licensing process, business structure, required documents, taxation, accounting system, intellectual property rights and labor laws.... Although most of the sections of Company law are similar for all companies operating in UAE however, Government of Abu Dhabi and other regions of UAE has established their own support forums to guide new investors.... The companies which are involved in viable business activities in Abu Dhabi are required to follow trade licenses law No....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Legal Implications of Construction Decisions: Converting a Country House into a Hotel

This will ensure that there is no infringement of copyright and intellectual property rights, as well as adherence to the provisions by the Company House.... A corporate structure is merited for providing a diverse team for managing an organization that has diverse individual interests and specializations, which is necessary for maintaining high levels of competitiveness for the company....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

Evolutionary Step in International Business Law

Thus, there was a need for protection of intellectual property which was a principle in GATT (Miller & Cross 2013, p.... The paper "Evolutionary Step in International Business law" highlights that with the development of technology, there has always been a need to regulate trade among different nations and states.... That is why there is a continuous development of the international law system.... The commerce laws had to cater for the rights of every nation because international law protects the nation but not an individual....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us