StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Hawthorne Effect: An Article Critique - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
"The Hawthorne Effect: An Article Critique" paper is aimed to discuss the article about the Hawthorne Effect and analyze the different components of the research conducted specifically the methods used to gather the result and to arrive at the conclusion…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.4% of users find it useful
The Hawthorne Effect: An Article Critique
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Hawthorne Effect: An Article Critique"

Based on the article, the Hawthorne effect works like an investment in the workforce. When people are given what they need such as proper compensation, workload, and even trust, they are bound to produce better results which then serve as rewards to the organization or company (Accel, 2010).

Based on the data presented by the article, the Hawthorne effect can be considered as an observable positive effect due to the attention given by superiors or researchers. There are underlying issues in such cases. Due to the probability of a Hawthorne effect, the credibility of the results of the study decreases. In an analysis of the Hawthorcasesffect and the empirical research undertaken in Hawthorn Works of the Western Electric Company, there are factors questionable in the research (Adaira, 1984).

One significant observation is related to the procedure undertaken. There are problems with the variables involved in the study. Basically, defining the variables in a study is the most important part of the procedure. But due to the lack of a clear definition of the Defininge Hawthorne effect study, the results are considered questionable. This is the main reason why Hawthe thorne effect became a concept of overestimated results. The study then conducted by Adaira presented ways and means to improve on the results and lessen the doubt in cases wherein there are perceived overestimation of results or effects considered unrealistically positive (1984).

Another study presented a radical criticism of the Hawthorne effect. According to Carey, there are discrepancies between the evidence in the study and the conclusions presented. The evidence showed the effects of rewards specifically financial can improve work morale and behavior. The conclusions on the other evidenced an improvement in the work output due to the attention given to the management specifically in the mucmuch-neededeaks between work hours. The said study pointed out the lack of evidence related to the conclusion (Carey, 1967).

Although the Hawthorne effect has created a negative influence in the field of research, there are groups who had taken its side such as the research conducted by Jones (1992). Based on the article, and the empirical evidence some groups have the original data from the Hawthorne Relay Assembly Test Room, as well as different forms of manipulations and combinations of variables. The study concluded that the conclusions can be considered valid and that there is slim or no evidence of the Hawthorne effect itself (Jones, 1992).

This result is interesting since the term “Hawthorn effect” had been used to describe a research ch result that was overestimated or inaccurate. The article presented by Accel (2010) is an explanation of a possible application of the Hawthorne effect. The term though can now be applied to the different fields of research wherein the conclusions are not supported by the evidence specifically in empirical studies. Addition discussion was then undertaken on the original Hawthorne experiment and the crievidenceat had been thrown at the said research through the years. These criticisms include the overestimation of results and the lack of evidence supporting the conclusions. 

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critique paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1409399-critique-paper
(Critique Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/other/1409399-critique-paper.
“Critique Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1409399-critique-paper.
  • Cited: 3 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Hawthorne Effect: An Article Critique

Critiques of Management Theories

These findings thus become the contributing factors to the strengths and weaknesses of the hawthorne effect.... the hawthorne Studies the hawthorne studies were an analysis which was conducted between 1927 and 1932 at Western Electric's Hawthorne Company in Cicero, Illinois.... This paper therefore gives an account of certain management theories by providing a detailed critique on each and how they affect organizational management....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

A Critique of Edgar Allan Poe's The Purloined Letter

A critique of Edgar Allan Poe's The Purloined Letter.... The confluence of Romantic and realist influences and social issues in the United States of America of the nineteenth century, The Purloined Letter has also been analyzed from a psychoanalyst perspective.... ... ... ny analysis of one of the short stories of one of America's greatest writers, Edgar Allan Poe needs to look at the economic, social and cultural aspects of the work....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Critique of a news article

“Hartshorne confirmed that older participants performed better than younger ones on a vocabulary test, but younger News article critique s News Article “The Smartest Age” The Atlantic - http www.... ?? (Khazan, 2015) Further in the article author also specifies, that Hartshorne and Germine “take a look at the ages at which.... ?? (Khazan, 2015) Further in the article author also specifies, that Hartshorne and Germine “take a look at the ages at which various types of cognitive performance crest” (Khazan, 2015)....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

RESEARCH CRITIQUE

In addition, the participants were aware that they were carrying out research, and since blinding was not possible hawthorne effect may distort the results.... This theory proposes that music produces the psychological response of altered mood leading to improved RESEARCH critique affiliation RESEARCH critique WHAT IS THE PROBLEM OR RESEARCH QUESTION?... Is there an effect of music on depression levels in older adults?...
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Factors Affecting Perception of Students on Hand Hygiene

This paper shall candidly and comprehensively critique the aforementioned article.... Firstly, research critique is an informed stepwise process of carefully and objectively gauging the weaknesses and strengths of a particular study with the particular motive of improving the research skills by effecting changes in the critiqued or apparently wrong or weak areas or sections.... A seminal moment in the nursing field has been published; Karen Lee's article 'student and infection prevention and control nurses' hand hygiene decision making in simulated clinical scenarios and the use of handwashing, gel, and glove' is one such article....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Transcendentalism in Literature

On the other hand, famous Romanticists include Charles Brockden Brown, William Cullen Bryant, James Fenimore Cooper, Nathaniel hawthorne, Washington Irving, Herman Melville and Edgar Allan Poe (Tanner 666).... From the paper "Transcendentalism in Literature" it is clear that Porte described Transcendentalist literature as one which relies heavily on the use of typical figures and on a dream, fantasy, parable or symbol in their exploration of usually large questions pertaining to art, history, and race....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Strategic Leadership

The paper "Strategic Leadership" aims to determine what is leadership and why is it important, to present Morgan's metaphors – leadership approach, leadership style, and relevant management theories, and to present a background of one's organization and sector.... ... ... ... This paper tells that the term leadership has received various definitions and explanations depending on the perceptions, experiences, and understandings of those who discuss it....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper

Guided Critical Review of a Journal Article

The paper "Guided Critical Review of a Journal Article" purposes to critique the appropriateness of the question that the research was designed to answer the research design; reliability and validity of the data as well as the data analysis approach in the study.... This comes from the claims that most patients suffering from minor stroke assume its effect....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us