StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Explicate Descartes Dream Argument - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Explicate Descartes Dream Argument" it is clear that when we are asleep we could feel things similar to when we are awake because we cannot tell whether we dreaming or not. It leads one to wonder whether we could just be constantly dreaming instead of being awake. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
Explicate Descartes Dream Argument
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Explicate Descartes Dream Argument"

In metaphysics, Rene Descartes proposed arguments for the existence of God showing the essence of matter and the extension of the mind. His major works include The Principles of Philosophy, Rules of Direction of the Mind, Treatise on Man, and Meditations on the First Philosophy among others.

In Descartes’ dream argument, he casts several doubts about the things he knew. First, he does not believe that all the information received by our senses is accurate. After his revelation, he undertook an intellectual rebirth. His first prompt was to throw away everything he knew and believed in before proving himself that they were satisfactory. He concluded that it would be difficult to analyze each idea individually, instead, he attacked the foundation. In his argument, he states that he often dreams of things that seem real in his sleep. In one dream where he sits by a fire, he can feel the warmth of the fire just like when he is awake. He concludes that if his senses can convey warmth while he is dreaming, then he cannot trust the fire exists when he feels it in his waking life. He goes ahead to argue that if we dream that our hands and bodies exist then they actually do. Even if certain objects do not exist, the basic colors that compose them exist. He trusts his perceptions of the existence of self-evident truths such as shapes and numbers because he believes in an omnipotent God who created these things.

Questions continue to flow in the human brain whether the knowledge we are gaining at any given time is true. He further states that he does not have a body, instead, it is a brain filled with information and illusions by a powerful being. Similarly, to justify that our senses deceive us, a person will have to recognize an error has occurred. In simple terms, one has to distinguish between being mistaken and being correct. It means one has to see the deceptions and avoid being deceived. Ironically, therefore, in the presentation of examples of how senses can deceive, one is also justifying that they can see through deceptions. This undercuts the very claim argued. Therefore, when Descartes argues that he is deceived by his senses, he is indirectly arguing that he has seen through these deceptions. From Descartes’ explanations we can state that the difference between understanding and imagining is that, when we understand, the mind turns towards itself and inspects its ideas, but with imagining, the mind creates something in the physical world that matches with the thing in mind. We can say that imagination only exists due to the presence of the body.

The thinker claims that it is impossible for us to tell whether we are dreaming or not. However, dreaming differs from being awake in many respects. He does not mean this literally though, he is merely trying to demonstrate that senses can be deceiving. First, the continuity available when one is awake does not exist in the dreamland. Things in the waking world remain the same daily, unlike the dream world where things can change. Similarly, the dream world and the waking world have different rules. For instance, in the dream world, the dead can walk and humans can fly among other strange things. As such, Descartes’ arguments do not warrant the amount and degree of skepticism that he holds.

Various key exceptions for Descartes’ arguments include, first, he does not consider even the existence of the external reality. Descartes’ claim is also unprecedented at least as Frans Burman made of their conversation in 1648. In the point that an omnipotent God has filled us with confusing knowledge, he is prone to error. There he was not as innovative as presumed since earlier thinkers had explored that premise. Similarly, one must dishonor claims to understanding or knowledge by demonstrating how they conflict with existing principles and views of knowledge.

Conclusion

Descartes considers the most remote possibilities of doubt, but it is difficult to attain a solid degree of doubt from his arguments. His skepticism undercuts itself in that, the doubt about possibilities such as being may undermine the greater doubt that should be generated by being. All the movements by the body as stated affect the functioning of the mind. However, Descartes’ arguments are calculated and well-driven but do not cast the required doubt.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Explicate Descartes dream argument, taking care to lay out what it Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1486352-explicate-descartes-dream-argument-taking-care-to
(Explicate Descartes Dream Argument, Taking Care to Lay Out What It Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1486352-explicate-descartes-dream-argument-taking-care-to.
“Explicate Descartes Dream Argument, Taking Care to Lay Out What It Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1486352-explicate-descartes-dream-argument-taking-care-to.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Explicate Descartes Dream Argument

Ontological argument - Rene Descartes

This research is aimed at elaboration of the famous doctrine of Ontological argument in the light of the philosophies elaborated by the ancient early Christian scholar St.... The researcher is determined to critically analyze Descartes' Ontological argument in the light of the doctrines articulated by Avicenna, St.... Since it is a basic research in nature and scope, the researcher will seek support from the material discussing the philosophy of the Medieval and Classical Eras, where the paper will examine the existence of Ontological argument in ancient times and influence of the Descartes' doctrine on the future philosophers....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

The Evolution of Consciousness, Ethical Treatment of Animals

descartes made a similar distinction, but one which drew on man's supposedly divine nature, asserting that while animals wield an intelligence that allows them to carry out basic tasks, such as finding shelter, this intelligence 'is of a significantly inferior type to the rational intelligence of man, which comes from his soul' (Kang, 117).... Ultimately, descartes decided that animal intelligence cannot be compared to that of humans, because animals are unable to reason or communicate verbally....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Religious Studies

He uses as support for his argument the idea that even God himself opted not to have automatons serving him on earth but instead imbued mankind with the ability to think and choose, for himself.... It will also draw from some of the great thinkers in history including John Hick, Immanuel Kant, David Hume, Isaac Newton, Karl Marx, Hildegard of Bingen, descartes, Stephen Hawking, and John Milton as well as the physical sciences and philosophical disciplines to provide evidence or disprove the existence of a higher power....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

The Nature of Descartes' Program of Radical Doubt and the Reason He Engages in This Program

6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Architecture as Engineering

The paper 'Architecture as Engineering' discusses architecture, which works in many ways to help shape and define a culture.... Rather than simply erecting a specific building, the work of the architect can contribute to the advancement of a society through its artistic achievement.... ... ... ... The author states that like art, what a building communicates about the customs and culture of the time in which it is built depends somewhat upon how it is viewed and used by the people around it....
15 Pages (3750 words) Article

2. The Semantics of 'I'

Rene descartes essentially presented his arguments with joint consideration of the method of doubt and of analysis, descartes ventured to cut into skepticism by demonstrating that if one were to take a systematized path to the unknown truths he initially doubted, then the....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Guarding Your Handprints

This is a thought in his dream and since the same scene can happen in reality, it leads to no argument that any thought having while asleep can also be realized in reality.... The main focus of the paper "Guarding Your Handprints" is on the ability of a dream to look like a reality, a real-life situation, capacity for reflection on one's current state, the function of the hands, biopsychology, neural communication, a subconscious part of our mind?... In the case of the dream doubt, we are prone to doubt our dreams, why?...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The History Of Psychology

It became a serious discipline when Rene descartes the French philosophers introduced the idea of dualism by asserting that the mind and body are two separate entities.... The paper "The History Of Psychology" describes what the history of philosophy dates back to to the ancient Greek when people like Aristotle and Plato even though it never emerged as a separate discipline....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us