StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Ancient and Medieval Political Theory - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Ancient and Medieval Political Theory" focuses on the critical thorough analysis of the main features of Ancient and Medieval political theory and their representatives. Plato and Aristotle both believe the “best” city is the most “just” city…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.8% of users find it useful
Ancient and Medieval Political Theory
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ancient and Medieval Political Theory"

ANCIENT AND MEDIEVAL POLITICAL THEORY no. ANCIENT AND MEDIEVAL POLITICAL THEORY Plato and Aristotle both believe the “best” city is the most “just” city. And yet, Plato supports monarchy and Aristotle supports aristocratic democracy. Why do they arrive at different notions of the “best” form of government? Who has the more persuasive argument? According to both Plato and Aristotle, the best city is the most just city since such cities serves everyone justly. However, according to Plato, monarchy is the best system of government that can provide citizens with the best city which is the most just city. On the contrary, Aristotle believes the aristocratic democracy is the best for the people. Nonetheless, Plato is highly convincing in defending why monarch is the best mode of government for the people than Aristotle’s contributions on the democratic government. It should be noted that, Plato’s support of monarchy as a system of government followed after the killing of Socrates for what was seen as not supporting the ideals of the government, the Athenian democracy. Socrates was killed on the basis that he never supported the Athenian god and that he corrupted their youths1. From this point of view, it is clear that democratic government are highly dictatorial that they are ready to eliminate any person seems to be opposing them. Following the death of Socrates, it is true to Plato’s ideas that democracy is unjust and corrupt system of governance. Plato also tried to examine different types of systems of governance and their principles towards determining which would lead to the best city which is the just city. Of all the systems of governments that existed then, Plato analyzed and realized that democracy was mainly military state that aimed at having honor. Democracy as it is in the current world as before, allow few individuals to rule over many2. It bring about the distinction between the rich and poor cities so are its people. This kind of division usually make some people to plot against others. The power of the democratic government is not in the people but in the money thereby making people lovers of money. According to Plato, democracy makes few private individuals to “accumulate gold in the treasury … and seeing another grow rich, seeks to rival him, and thus the great mass of the citizens become lovers of money3. . . . And so at last, instead of loving contention and glory, men become lovers of trade and money; they honor and look up to the rich man, and make a ruler of him, and dishonor the poor man4.” In this sense, Plato denotes that democracy divides people into classes of poor and rich. Hence, in democracy the poor tend to work hard to rich the poor and the rich will ever use all means possible to remain above board; therefore, leading to corruption. Since the poor will see the rich as corrupt and lead better life, then this system of government usually creates war between the rich and the poor. According to Plato, since “the excessive increase of anything often causes a reaction in the opposite direction5,” at immense corruption and discrimination, the poor may wedge war against the rich. Plato states that, “excess of liberty, whether in states or individuals, seems only to pass into excess of slavery6.” This statements note that, democratic systems of governments often fool the mass that the power is in their hands, but in the real sense, they are slaves of the rich. Hence, once the poor feel that the rich are increasingly oppressing them, they often reach a limit that they overturn these types of governments to put their own (the poor). This has happened in numerous states in the world. These evil characteristics and nature of democratic systems of government, Plato opted for monarchy where there is importance and advantages of laws. In monarchy, law cannot be corrupted in the favor of few people or an individual; therefore, according to Plato, when one had “entered into an implied contract that he will do as . . . [the laws] command him7.” In this type of governance, everyone is subjected to the law equally. In stressing this fact, Plato stated that, “in my view, is not far off; but if law is the master of the government and the government is its slave, then the situation is full of promise and men enjoy all the blessings that the gods shower on a state8.” Therefore, an “ideal and just state is an aristocracy9” and provides the best rule that leads to the best and just city. Contrary to Plato’s, Aristotle argued that only democracy can lead to best which is the just city. By definition, democracy is considered as the rule of people that usually arises due to lack of equity. If democracy is pegged on the lack of equity, how then can it lead to best and more just city? For instance, most African states are democratically governed and they are the most corrupt states in the world; therefore, democracy is not the best system of governance. According to Aristotle, Plato was an idealist whose real state would “contain two states in one, each hostile to the other . . . . [Plato] makes the guardians [the warriors] into a mere occupying garrison, while the husbandmen and artisans and the rest are the real citizens10.” Moreover, he noted monarchy require many laws, but “having so good an education, the citizens will not need many laws . . . but then he confines his education to the guardians11.” These are ideas are not well convincing in that without law there will be no order. Additionally, what measure of education will bring order when there are no systems regulating and moderating such orders? Therefore, a lawless city attributed by lawless government will only make the city corrupt and not fit for all human races within it. However, Aristotle’s aimed at considering “not only what form of government is best, but also what is possible and what is easily attainable12.” This is best for human race and for the just city, since it considered every person within the city. Not everyone can be equal; hence, it is proper to have a government that will have practical and attainable policies and according to Aristotle, that was democratic government. This idea and contribution was perfectly placed but it does not define or constitute the known elements of a democratic governance where few people govern the state affairs. Therefore, Aristotle ideals are welcomed, but they are not supportive of ideal characteristics that propel democratic governance. Aristotle could have realized that democratic government usually have a lot of promises that are defined in their constitutions and manifestoes to the people, but in reality such promises are never fulfilled since they will lead to equality. “True” constitution must serve the interests of the common citizens, but democratic governments’ constitutions are usually “Despotic” since they only serve the interest of the selfish leaders and their specific interest groups13. Therefore, democracy can never bring the best cities which is the just cities. In other words, democracy is a form of “arbitrary power of an individual or individuals . . . responsible to no one, [which] governs . . . with a view to its own advantage, not to that of its subjects, and therefore against their will14.” It should be noted that Aristotle also desired kingship or the monarchy, but he noted that this kind of governance has high possibilities of turning into a tyranny. However, Plato considered it as a governance with wisdom since the kings were trained into philosophers who in turn led with wisdom and took all their subjects as one and without discriminations15. With the philosophy learned by persons to be kings, there are no ways that their regimes could turn into tyranny. Additionally, the leaders of these governments were chosen before they were born; therefore, they can never rule with sense of discrimination or favors. On the other hand, democratic leaders are put in leadership through their popularity, form statistic, most of them often favor those who put them power and discriminate upon those who oppose them. Despite the difference in ideas on the ideal and best governance that leads to best and more just society, an ideal society is difficult to find. All the systems of governance have their weaknesses as well as their strengths; however, governance that places the subject at the center of the government is the best since it will provide justice to all. On the contrary, democratic government is never the best since the power among all other resources are in the hand of the few. These few are more powerful than the rest of the citizens. This kind of distinction often creates classes of the rich and poor despite both living in the same society. This therefore often create the rich cities and poor cities; hence, it is impractical that a democratic regime that creates different status in terms of class generated by resources allocation and accumulation can lead to the best and more just cities. In other words, there is no justices in the society without equality. The equality will always create a rift between the classes that are already defining the society. Therefore, despite the limitations of monarch, it is the best form of governance the can create the “best” city which is the most “just” city compared to the democratic system of governance. Notes Alvey, Jim. 2011. A short history of ethics and economics the Greeks. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Pub. Aristotle, and C. D. C. Reeve. 2014. Nicomachean ethics. http://public.eblib.com/choice/publicfullrecord.aspx?p=1643868.Anagnostopoulos, Constitutional Rights Foundation. 2010. BRIA 26 1 Plato and Aristotle on Tyranny and the Rule of Law. Volume 26, No. 1. Retrieved December 8, 2014, http://www.crf-usa.org/bill-of-rights-in-action/bria-26-1-plato-and-aristotle-on-tyranny-and-the-rule-of-law.html Davis, Michael, and Aristotle. 1996. The politics of philosophy a commentary on Aristotles Politics. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield. Georgios. 2009. A companion to Aristotle. Chichester, U.K.: Wiley-Blackwell. Klosko, George. 2012. History of political theory: an introduction. Volume 1, Volume 1. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Plato, and H. D. P. Lee. 1966. The republic. Baltimore: Penguin Books. Plato, Giovanni R F Ferrari, and Tom Griffith. 2001. The Republic. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ Pr. Rubin, Leslie G. 1997. Justice v. law in Greek political thought. Lanham [u.a.]: Rowman & Littlefield. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Ancient and Medieval Political Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words - 3, n.d.)
Ancient and Medieval Political Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words - 3. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1849803-ancient-and-medieval-political-theory
(Ancient and Medieval Political Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words - 3)
Ancient and Medieval Political Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words - 3. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1849803-ancient-and-medieval-political-theory.
“Ancient and Medieval Political Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words - 3”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1849803-ancient-and-medieval-political-theory.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ancient and Medieval Political Theory

International Relations

This paper ''International Relations'' tells that Plato was the first to establish a theory that was considered to include both political power and political leadership legitimization.... Thus, through his various contributions Plato is perceived to play a key role in the establishment of the ancient d medieval poll theory.... hellip; Plato has the political doctrine attributed to him, it was mainly obtained from the statesman, the laws and, even from the republic Taylor, (121-122)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

John Lockes Social Contract Theory

Jon Locke's Social Contract theory and its Compatibility with the Republican Ideologies of Niccolo Machiavelli Admission Number & Number Instructor Introduction Republicanism is a political ideology embraced by the members of a republic.... Particularly, the essay explores the extent to which Jon Locke's social contract theory is compatible with the republican ideologies of Niccolo Machiavelli.... This theory explains the processes of forming states and governments....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

IS POLITICAL SCIENCE SCIENTIFIC

Though research methods like statistics, stating and testing of hypothesis, drawing of inferences and supporting a political theory with observable facts, and making political analysis thereof, is commonly practiced, yet, political science is not considered an exact science like physics, chemistry, and mathematics.... An empirical theory of politics, then, is an explanation of why people behave the way they do politically (The Powermutt* Project).... This is because, although, some postulates can be proved true but they are not as fixed, rigid and universally true as the Laws of Motion, Laws of Thermodynamics, Quantum theory, etc....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Modern Social Imaginaries

And it is this idea of order that underlines all political theory, and all current government, using ideas that are all based off of Grotius, Locke, and Pufendorf.... And this is where the modern idea of order split from the medieval, Christian ways, into a sense of order that is here and now, not to be judge later.... From this we can see that the whole idea of order can be one of two things, a higher order and morality that is the Ultimate, such as the ancient order of Sainthood, or it can be a rational experience in the current time and the present, and if that is the case the whole idea of order is very much rational and perceived....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

IMPRINTS AND IMPRESSIONS: MILESTONES IN HUMAN PROGRESS

For me, Plato's theory is of special interest, since as well as Plato I believe in the existence of absolute ethical principles that are the foundation of human morality.... The works of each of these thinkers are a valuable source of human knowledge, giving one the ability to open a new world of… Ancient editions of these books introduces the readers to the great past having its unique historical and scientific significance. In his writings, Plato considered particularly important ethical, religious, social and political issues....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Neo-Classic Architecture and its Reliance on the Ancients

The process of architectural theory, as we know from a modern study, is a continuous process.... The present paper "Neo-Classic Architecture and its Reliance on the Ancients" would describe how the general principles of visual art in an architecture of ancient Rome and Greece is reflected in the more modern, neoclassical architecture specifically in England.... Within this chaotic world of change and instability, architects, artists, and writers turned to the solid foundations of the ancient world, the 'classics', attempting to discover a solid base in what would come to be termed the Neoclassical period....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Ancient Medieval Thinkers - Comprehensive Philosophy Knowledge Required

Modern political philosophers like Hobbes and Locke said that all human society was artificial, based on agreement, knowing that they were rejecting Aristotle's claim.... This assignment "Ancient medieval Thinkers - Comprehensive Philosophy Knowledge Required" discusses an evaluation of how Aristotle tried to connect philosophy and politics, based on your reading of the text and Schall's article....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Comparison of High Reliability Theory and Normal Accident Theory

"Comparison of High-Reliability theory and Normal Accident theory" paper states that both theories emphasize the significance of learning from mistakes.... The supporters of the two standpoints differ in their evaluation of the possibility of gathering evidence about these securities-related actions....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us