StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of Terri Schiavo - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Analysis of Terri Schiavo Case" paper examines the case which is a description of a legal struggle concerning prolonged life support in the U.S.A. Terri Schiavo sustained a permanent injury on the brain due to lack of oxygen after collapsing in the hall of her apartment on 25 February 1990…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful
Analysis of Terri Schiavo Case
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of Terri Schiavo"

Terri Schiavo Case Analysis Terri Schiavo’s case is a of a legal struggle concerning prolonged life supporting in the in the U.S.A. Terri Schiavo sustained a permanent injury on the brain due to lack oxygen after collapsing in the hall of her apartment on 25 February, 1990 at the age of 26 years. She had not prepared a living will, and she did not have a durable attorney’s power. Four months after her injury, she was rendered incompetent and her husband, Mr Schiavo was appointed her lawful guardian without opposition from her parents. The brain injury had rendered her incapable to swallow and to keep her nourished and alive; a feeding tube was placed on her. Later in the year 1990, Mrs. Shiavo was diagnosed with a “Persistent Vegetative State” (PVS). Her husband Mr. Schiavo accepted that her condition was very critical, and her recovery was remote since all healthcare means had failed to revive her. He decided to work on what he assumed his wife would wish. He said my wife would not have chosen to continue being kept on an artificial life-supporting machine. Mrs. Shiavo’s parents strongly opposed her husband’s stand and subsequently one of the most popular ethical dilemmas unfolded (Perry,Churchill and Kirshner, 2005). This case spurred controversy in the legal, medical, ethical, political and social domains. The case threatened to loosen the long-standing legal and ethical positions, which enabled individuals to control medical interventions executed on them. After so many petitions, hearings and numerous appeals, the Florida Supreme Court sanctioned the feeding tube to be removed on 31 of March 2005 in spite of opposition from President George Bush and the Congress but she died on 31 of March 2005. Terri’s case resonated with other cases that obviously influenced the Supreme Court’s decision to have the feeding tube removed, which included, the case of “Karen Quinlan Ann in 1976,” “Paul Brophy in 1986,” and “Nancy Cruzan in 1990” in which the patients who didn’t have written advance directives. In all these cases, the courts viewed the freedom and privacy interest of the patients as supreme and thus, the judge argued that she would not have wished to continue living under life-prolonging measures all her life hence sanctioned the that the feeding tube be remove from her (Perry, Churchill and Kirshner, 2005) A number of legal considerations were put into perspective in the determination of this case. Firstly, she had not made any healthcare directive other than private conversations with her husband in, which she stated, or the husband deduced that she would not want her life to be prolonged if she fell in a PVS. Without such advance health care directive, the decision to terminate the artificial nourishment and hydration had to be made by the husband who was the legal guardian. Being a person who knew her well, he was the best-suited surrogate decision maker for her. On the other hand, the numerous appeals, hearings and petitions on the case that delayed its determination for many years were because, withholding artificial hydration and nourishment of patients in chronic vegetative state is not considered illegal in the state of Florida Judicial systems (Mathes, 2005), Various people and institutions took different positions regarding Schiavos case. The parent’s stand was motivated by their belief that; Terri could recover with hypobaric chamber therapy since she could swallow. However, the most convincing motivation for their stand was that of their emotional belief of “not killing” based on their Catholic Church religious beliefs position, on euthanasia and the desire to keep alive their loved one as parents and hence it was justifiable for the parents to oppose the termination of the artificial life support. As parents, they had the right to maintain her life if they desired to do so (Ditto, 2000). Many taxpayers could have supported the Supreme Courts ruling due to the resources required to keep someone suffering from an irreversible condition alive for fifteen because they bear the tax burden. The governors of Florida’s position to have Terri remain under artificial nutrition and hydration was influenced by the idea of autonomy, or the patient’s preferences. Governor Bush once reordered that the feeding tube be reinserted after its removal through one of the court’s sanctions by signing Terri’s law, which provided for the governor’s discretion to order resumption of Terri’s medical treatment (Perry, Churchill and Kirshner, 2005). The moral justification of the governor’s stand can be justified on his personal beliefs on human life and the custom of not wanting to deviate from the prevailing public opinion on Euthanasia related issues (Preston &Kelly, 2006). The opinion of the outsiders on the case was influenced by characteristics, values, beliefs, economic and social gains or losses of the opposing persons in the case. For instance, the personal religious persuasions of Terri’s parents could have played a major role in wanting her to remain alive. The Relationship of Terri’s loved ones and the outsider’s ability to associate with either the husband or the parents may have influenced their standpoint in this case. In addition, their concern and care not to harm emotions of either the parents or the husband through their personal opinions or perceived personal characteristics of the persons involved in the dispute could have influenced their position in this case. Therefore, their varying positions can be justified on our general human character to consider the impact of our ethical decisions on cultural or religious groups and institutions that we believe will be an influenced by these decisions (Preston and Kelly, 2006). The husband’s position can be attributed to the fact that all attempts to help her recover had failed. He was justified on this situation to propose the feeding tube to be remove from her, putting into consideration that he was convinced, as a husband that Terri would have wished for the same if she were in a capacity to express herself (Ditto, 2006). My ethical position in this case is that the court of Supreme did more harm than good by its final ruling. Although her condition was terminal, authorizing the removal of the tube, and her subsequent death violated the dominant ethical belief of maintaining life. This may give rise to situations where lives are terminated,even when the patient’s case is not irreversible, by using the law that allows courts to determine the incapacitated patient’s best interests or who is suited best to decide for them (Mathes, 2005). Public health consideration arises in Terri’s case. It entails preventing illness, promoting health and prolonging life. The main issue is the actual methods that should be used in prolonging life and what are the exceptional cases where life should not be prolonged (Mathes, 2005). Terri Schiavo’s case is an ideal illustration of how ethics, law, values and beliefs can come into conflict. It places importance on the need for sound decision-making and the framework to deal with legal and ethics dilemmas in order to avoid recurrence of spectacles such as in this case. I now consider implementing my advance directive in the form of a specific statement regarding the types of life-sustaining treatment I would want to receive. This will help to avoid conflicts in decision making among various stakeholders as it happened in Shiavos case (Hook & Mueller, 2005). Vegetative state refers to a situation where a patient loses consciousness because of injury on brain (Fins, 2008). Higher brain death is the stoppage of functioning in brain parts responsible for consciousness and advanced thinking (Wijdicks, 2001). After her death and autopsy had been done, “the coroner implied that Terri was not in a minimally stable state. She had massive brain damage. Her brain weight was approximated to be half the normal weight. Her remaining brain regions showed severe hypoxic injury and neuronal atrophy/loss” (Pence, 2011). Therefore, the autopsy leads me to conclude that her husband made the right decision for her after all. References Ditto, P. (2006). What Would Terri Want? On the Psychological Challenges of Surrogate Decision Making (1st ed.). California: Taylor &Francis Group. Fins, J. (2008). Brain Injury:The Vegetative and Minimally Conscious States. (1st ed., pp. 15-20). Newyork: The Hastings Center. Hook, C. C., & Mueller, P. S. (2005). The Terri Shiavo Saga: The making of a tragedy and Lessons learned. Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 80, 1449-1460. Matthes, M. (2005). Terri Shiavo and End of Life Decisions: Can Law Help Us Out?. Med Nursing, 14(3), 200-202. Preston, T., & Kelly, M. (2006). A Medical Ethics Assessment of the Case of Terri Schiavo (1st ed.). Washington: Taylor &Francis Group. Pence, G. E. (2011). Medical Ethics: Accounts of Ground-Breaking Cases (6th ed.). (M. Ryan, Ed.). New York, NY: McGraw Hill Perry, J. E., Churchill, L. R., & Kirshner, H. S. (2005). The Terri shiavo case: Legal, Ethical and medical perspectives. Annals of Internal Medicine, 143, 744-748. Wijdicks, E. F. (2001). The diagnosis of brain death. New England Journal of Medicine, 344(16), 1215-21 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Sciavo Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Sciavo Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1655301-sciavo-case
(Sciavo Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Sciavo Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1655301-sciavo-case.
“Sciavo Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1655301-sciavo-case.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of Terri Schiavo Case

Euthanasia Terri Schiavo Case

This research paper "Euthanasia terri schiavo case" shows that my topic will be on Euthanasia that refers to putting an end to a sick person's life for alleviation of pain, agony, and suffering.... For instance, I will be using terri schiavo's case (coma from 1990 – 2005 March) as an example because it is relevant to this critical discussion.... I would apply the aforementioned ethical principles to the case and discuss if Euthanasia is ethical or unethical....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Case analysis on Terri Schiavo

Conclusion I doubt that my thoughts on this matter would have impacted the parents or husband of terri schiavo any differently than the way it did.... Some remarked that the schiavo case was a “dark moment” in the history of American health policy—blurring the lines between what life is and is not and taking the place of “God” in determining when a person must die.... Case Analysis on terri schiavo terri schiavo died on March 31, 2005....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Theresa Schiavo Law Case Study

Several issues are associated with the terri schiavo case, such as ethical, psychological, medical, religious, legal, and philosophical.... Several issues are associated with the terri schiavo case, such as ethical, psychological, medical, religious, legal, and philosophical.... Researchers, on the terri schiavo case have analyzed what would happen when a patient lacks advance directives, or when one is not able to express one's own wants due to cognitive loss or being in Persistent Vegetative State (PVS)....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Stereotypes in the Media

Stereotypes in the media exist in every society of the world in present times and the same has been the case for so many decades now that it all seems so very inevitable.... The paper "Stereotypes in the Media" discusses that it would be wise to state here that the threat posed by the stereotyping within media is immense and it needs to be clamped if we want our coming generations to survive in a society that has freedom for all and sundry....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Doctor-Assisted Suicide

The name terri schiavo should ring a bell in every person's mind.... t has been the most renowned case in the history of America regarding doctor-assisted suicide.... This case shows that doctor-assisted suicide was the best way to let Terri die and finish off her sufferings once and for all.... terri died nearly two weeks after the removal of the feeding tube on March 31, 2005....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

The Impact of Media Language on Audiences

This paper discusses the impact of media language on audiences.... The paper analyses recent studies which have shown how the masses take greater notice of media texts with writers trying to involve as much action as they possibly can to heighten the sensitivities of the receiver.... ... ... ... Body language, constant stressing on certain words, and using words that would naturally produce a sensation are great weapons for experienced communicators (Edwards, 1982)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

The Impact of Roe v. Wade Decision Case on the U.S. Society

Wade case has opened a door to investigate into the nooks of this choice for the abortion especially in instances where the woman's health is challenged or when the pregnancy results from rape or incest.... Wade is a United States Supreme Court case in the year 1973 that resulted in a landmark verdict regarding abortion.... The central verdict that came out of the Roe Vs Wade case made abortion permissible for any cause that a woman shows during the initial 12 week time....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

An Individuals Right to Refuse Medical Care

In this piece, the following elements will be analyzed: the historical perspective (including a brief history of the schiavo case through the judicial system and the legislature); a brief discussion on an individual's right to refuse medical care; and the moral and ethical issues present in the case.... The paper 'terri schiavo's Case - One's Right to Refuse Medical Care, Ethical Issues, Health Policy Issues" is a breathtaking example of a case study on health sciences & medicine....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us