StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
'Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles" paper compares and contrasts these two articles to determine which one is a more persuasive and effective discussion on the issue of single-sex classrooms. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93% of users find it useful
Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles"

Download file to see previous pages

Learning institutions today are faced with the issue of whether there is indeed an advantage in creating single-sex classrooms.  Two articles were written to present both sides of the issue.  The first article “Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum” by Barnett and Rivers debunks the idea that girls and boys who attend single-sex classrooms perform better than their counterparts in a coed environment (Barnett and Rivers 539). The authors claim that research shows that the difference in the cognitive abilities of girls and boys is trivial; thus, there is no gain in opting for single-sex classrooms in public schools.

Aside from the high cost of setting up these classrooms, it also goes against the federal law which requires that schools should make available their resources to both sexes. The authors conclude their article by stating that single-sex classrooms do not make any sense. On the other hand, Reed’s essay, “Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms” takes the opposite side by arguing that “single-sex education is a valid and compelling option” (Reed 542). The article mentions that the learning styles of girls and boys differ; therefore, there is a need to promote single-sex classrooms.

 In the fourth paragraph, Reed cites a study of secondary schools and colleges which showed that single-sex schools for females provide better educational opportunities and occupational achievements (Reed 542). On the other hand, Barnett’s and Rivers’ style is less direct. They do not present their position in the first part of the essay; rather, they mention about a school’s superintendent plan to create two single-sex public schools. Unlike Reed, the readers are not made aware of their stand until the middle part of the essay.

The style of Barnett and Rivers is to show examples of single-sex classrooms and how it affects the performance of the students. The mention of statistics is not predominant in the article unlike that of Reed’s. Barnett and Rivers’ article lacks the support of statistical data. They mention that the theory that there are major gender differences in the processing of information between boys and girls has been debunked but they fail to present evidence of such, unlike Reed who supports her theories by citing statistics.

The use of statistics makes Reed’s article more convincing and believable. A notable style of Barnett and Rivers is shown in paragraph 8. Contrary to Reed’s style, they include a statement in their article that single-sex classrooms are good provided the resources are there (Barnett and Rivers 540). They agreed to the opposing position but immediately contradict it by saying that there is a catch to it. Reed on the other hand, never mentions that coed classrooms are good. Instead, she strengthens her position by presenting the drawbacks of her argument but refutes it by discussing the results of the research made among more than 450 schools (Reed 542).

  

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Article, n.d.)
Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Article. https://studentshare.org/education/1460582-compare-and-contrast-two-articles-with-opposite
(Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Article)
Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Article. https://studentshare.org/education/1460582-compare-and-contrast-two-articles-with-opposite.
“Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Article”. https://studentshare.org/education/1460582-compare-and-contrast-two-articles-with-opposite.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles

Analyzing Article on the Origin of Modern Man

The out-of-Africa theory was tested according to which “a single dispersal from Africa followed by separate migrations from this ancestral non-African source population, and this scenario receives the strongest support from the data (P = 0.... Date: Abstract Today, the origin of modern man is explained by two different hypotheses- the multiregional and the out-of-Africa hypothesis....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Culturally Responsive Pedagogy

It also shows that a multicultural or multilingual classroom is one where a multicultural responsive approach is applied to make the students realize that their backgrounds are long-term assets for them that they can utilize in their learning period and teachers should also know how to teach diverse students in a harmonious environment.... Students from diverse cultural backgrounds should be encouraged to share their views so that teachers have a better idea of eliminating their complexes that may originate gradually....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

National Curriculum for Scientific Education

There should be a great similarity between what a people feels right and what is actually right (Rosen, 2014).... Additionally, one should be able to identify the appropriateness of what s require from them.... Scientific scope refers to the ability of the interventions to consider the personal results as recorded by individuals....
7 Pages (1750 words) Article

Gender and Preferred Content in Childrens Drawing among Selected Primary School Children

nbsp; While Goodenough's initial study on gender and children's drawings in 1926 found that girls drew “better” than boys when it comes to proportion and detail, it has just raised more questions than it has given answers.... But it seems that the more researchers study gender's role in children's drawings, the more questions are asked, which should be looked at as a positive event as validated studies proving that gender certainly has an influence on how children draw pictures in detail, proportion, form, and style and children's approach to drawing, subject preference, and content....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

The Core Curriculum Beyond Tourism

­Squires (1987) observes that specifying what needs to be included and developing a curriculum for a vocational disciple from such specifications could be theoretically possible.... This article "The Core curriculum Beyond Tourism" describes the content of the academic subject knowledge in tourism education.... Woollard (1996) carries out the argument for a standard curriculum to deal with a crisis of accountability witnessed in higher education....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Media Impact on Young Girls

This paper "Media Impact on Young girls" discusses the impact of the media on young girls that has adverse effects more than a positive effect.... There is pressure for the girls to look picture perfect and have the same body images as the unrealistic images in the magazines.... hellip; The work of the role model is to ensure the young girls know their self-worth, and the real beauty lies in hard work and determination in being better than what they are at the moment (Cochrane 15)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Adolescent Boys and Body Image: Weight and Muscular Concerns as Dual Pathways to Body Dissatisfaction

The paper "Adolescent boys and Body Image: Weight and Muscular Concerns as Dual Pathways to Body Dissatisfaction" discusses the possibility of whether or not a young adolescent boy will have body image issues when considering his weight and muscle mass.... When compared to girls, weight as measured by the body mass index, the higher the BMI levels also result in negative body image for boys.... nbsp; A pattern appears that muscular build and weight do contribute to body dissatisfaction in adolescent boys....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Womens Rights in Saudi Arabia

audi women instigated a right-to drive campaign that gained attention from international media and other conservative authorities in Saudi Arabia.... efore the “I Will drive Starting June 17th” Facebook page was removed by the Saudi authorities it read in part, “We women in Saudi Arabia, from all nationalities, will start driving our cars by ourselves....
8 Pages (2000 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us