StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Critique of the America's Constitution:A Biography by Akhil Amar - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
Subject: History and Political Science Date: March 30, 2012 Topic: Critique of book "America's Constitution: A Biography" by Akhil Amar Introduction This is the book with a difference, on America’s Constitution. It introduces an inquisitive reader with the constitutional text and the various stages of struggles of the legislators and intellectuals, before they asserted, “We do,” to experience the enlightenment and spirit of the Constitution…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
Critique of the Book Americas Constitution:A Biography by Akhil Amar
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Critique of the America's Constitution:A Biography by Akhil Amar"

Download file to see previous pages

Akhil Reed Amar writes, “Law, history and political science—these three disciplines form the legs of the stool on which the book rests.”(467) He gives an elaborate description about the ‘birth-pangs’ of the Constitution, the virtual neck to neck to competition amongst the proposers and those who opposed the constitutional provisions, before they give the assent by a wafer-thin majority vote( in most of the states), and how that passage leads to further vigorous debates. He argues, “The Constitution has given rise to a remarkable range of interpretations over the years.

In the chapters that follow I offer my own take: This book is an opinionated biography of the document. I pay special attention to these aspects of the Constitution that are, in my view, particularly significant, or generally misunderstood.”(Preface, xii) Response to the scholarship of the author: My response to the contents of the book is positive and appreciative. Akhil makes his intentions clear and he writes, “As one who teaches in both a law school and a political-science department, I have written this book to help show my colleagues what they are missing.”(467) This is no self-eulogy, but a statement of facts.

The contents are not an academic exercise in textual analysis. Behind each explanation and interpretation, the author sees the issues that confront an average American citizen and he gives opinionated statements as to what democracy means to them and what democracy should mean to them. The author has the traits of a sociologist and spiritualist clubbed together when he argues, “And yet….in important ways the document did worsen the plight of those most cruelly denied the blessings of liberty.

Slavery was the original sin in the New World garden, and the Constitution did more to feed the serpent than to crush it.”(20) This observation is but one of the many such examples when the author uses the interpretative method to highlight his viewpoints on contentious issues that challenge the American society. He is in search of a human face, not a heartless legal robot, behind the interpretation of articles of the Constitution and looks at them with a holistic perspective. Akhil is aware of certain shortcomings of the constitution and the biography is still not complete!

The un-enacted topics include foundational statues, judicial interpretation and norms and practices of American system. Akhil highlights the concern of the Founders who were fully seized of the issue of “the legitimacy of the Constitution” depends on popular support and supremacy of the common citizen. This was the acid test for those involved directly or indirectly in drafting of the articles of Constitution. The emphasis in the forwarding document “to Congress presenting the Constitution,” they specifically called for the approval by the convention.

The citizens of the concerned States were afforded an opportunity to discuss and study it before the election which was only about “delegates to be selected for the conventions.” Akhil argues that the voting power given to the delegates to the convention is equivalent to pattern of “direct referendum on the document.” (308) Akhil has elucidated three important themes: 1. The Founder's Constitution was more democratic, but stood by

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critique of the Book America's Constitution:A Biography by Akhil Amar Report/Review”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1446398-critique-of-book-america-s-constitution-a
(Critique of the Book America'S Constitution:A Biography by Akhil Amar Report/Review)
https://studentshare.org/history/1446398-critique-of-book-america-s-constitution-a.
“Critique of the Book America'S Constitution:A Biography by Akhil Amar Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1446398-critique-of-book-america-s-constitution-a.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critique of the Book America's Constitution:A Biography by Akhil Amar

Book analysis

Book Review: Operation Dark Heart Grade Course (November 22nd, 2013) Book Review: Operation Dark Heart the book; Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan – And the Path to Victory, by Lt.... Most notably, the book gives an account of operations that had been undertaken and geared towards blocking the Taliban's resurgence and granting the USA military victory in that war, and then turns to elaborate on the tipping point of the top brass of the USA army the involvement in the operations, which then watered down an apparent victory into a failure (Shaffer, 2010)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

Benjamin Harrison by Charles Calhoun

The author of the book compellingly and convincingly discusses the legacy of Benjamin Harrison, including the social set-up of the era.... the book focuses on the military and political life of Benjamin Harrison, right… A S Benjamin studied law, he increasingly became interested in politics.... In addition, the book explores his stint at the military during the American Civil War ere he rose to become a colonel, to his running for the presidency in 1888, where he won and served for one term, becoming the one and only president in the history of the United States of America to be preceded and succeeded by the same person, Grover Cleveland (Calhoun 17)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review

Book Review - The Bill of Rights: Creation and Reconstruction by Akhil Reed Amar

However, the American government s been confronted by challenging times in her bid to develop, rule herself and stand out as a democratically outstanding government in the whole world especially during the tenure of President Bill Clinton when the laws concerning the bills of rights were gravely breached It is premised on this that professor Akhil Reed amar writes his book ‘The Bill of Rights: Creation and Reconstruction' in which he criticizes how Clinton's breach of concerning the human rights laws....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Book critique

However, the key characters of the book are not the individuals in power; but rather these individuals who were tasked with the demanding labor.... the book points on the massive fortunes that were made by unscrupulous individuals and the business men who risked their money and subsequently their business.... Ambrose employs a story telling device as a tool to propagate his… The main characters of this book are the military personnel, politicians, businessmen and the blue collar individuals....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Book Review of How Democratic Is the American Constitution by Robert A. Dahl second edition

the book acts as a reminder.... Dahl, touching on the subject matter of democracy and the American constitution.       The American constitution often acts as a reference to the American democracy's foundation.... The reminder is the constitution of American differs greatly from the democratic system only possible basis.... Dahl considers the constitution in the light of issues with consideration of the historical circumstances, which surrounded its creation....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Biography

In the book “The Everyday life of Abraham Lincoln”, the author, Francis Fisher Browne, uses Abraham Lincoln as an icon of personality and character.... In the book “The Everyday life of Abraham Lincoln”, the author, Francis Fisher Browne, uses Abraham Lincoln as an icon of personality and character.... This biography was written twenty five years after the death of Abraham Lincoln.... As a result of this, the main idea of here> here> 5th March, biography of Abraham Lincoln The main idea for this book was character....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

The Development of the Human Civilization

A considerable part of the book is devoted to showing... To begin with, it may be important to dwell on some important ideas that were articulated in the book in question.... This paper will carry out an analysis and critique of A.... Indeed, different forms of religion can be traced almost up to the very dawn of society....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

Analysis of How Democratic Is the American Constitution Book by Robert A. Dahl

It reveals the fact that the American political system lacks the multi-party politics… One of the positive aspects of the book is that it is readily accessible and is a brief summary of the reasons why the United States Constitution requires to be amended.... Looking at the book, for instance, only a few pages of the book talk about the debate between the parliamentary and presidential systems that may lead to a new democracy Its brief nature is indeed an added advantage to the readers as opposed to if the book tried to cover all aspects of the Constitution that are already reviewed in records....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us