StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Ayatollah versus the Ambassador: The Influence of Religion on Politics in Post-Saddam Iraq - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Ayatollah versus the Ambassador: The Influence of Religion on Politics in Post-Saddam Iraq" paper argues that the strategy of separation of politics and religion failed since CPA lost all control of the process. Bremer’s lack of acknowledgment of the great ayatollah was his major flaw. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Ayatollah versus the Ambassador: The Influence of Religion on Politics in Post-Saddam Iraq
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ayatollah versus the Ambassador: The Influence of Religion on Politics in Post-Saddam Iraq"

Ayatollah versus the Ambassador: The Influence of Religion on Politics in Post-Saddam Iraq Ayatollah versus the Ambassador: TheInfluence of Religion on Politics in Post-Saddam Iraq Lieutenant Paul Jerry Bremer, head of the Coalition Provisional Authority (CPA), seemed to bear unmistakable notions about a kind of ideal Iraq after the execution of Saddam in 2003. They were sure that some of the Iraqis, especially the Shia, would support their endeavor and help them achieve their objective. However, the USA faced immense opposition from an individual originating from the Shia community, who utilized both religious influence and appeal to Iraqi nationalism in order to marshal his supporters, proving that organizations and organizational assessment (TSDM 26) is a vital ingredient in achievement of objectives (Naval War Coll Newport RI, 2010). Sayyid Ali al-Husayni was the influential individual who posed a threat to the plans of the USA government on Iraq. Holding a position equivalent to that of the Catholic pope, Sayyid was considered unfailing when it came to the issuing of decrees about morals or faith. He bore the topmost comprehension and interpretation of Islamic dictums especially among the Shia. According to media reports, the British and USA planned on drafting a new constitution for Iraq. The ayatollah, Sayyid, gave a declaration that only elected representatives had that kind of authority. His argument was that if the constitution was to be formulated by other nations, there is no guarantee that its contents would have the best interests of Iraq at heart or express their identity as a nation (Naval War Coll Newport RI, 2010). Formulation of strategies coupled with their execution is crucial when it comes to effective execution of policies (TSDM 24). For efficient leadership, leaders need to be critical thinkers and be able to acknowledge the value of structured organizational analysis. Bremer and his team did not recognize the complications that the decree issued had on their plans. Due to their lack of knowledge about the Iraqi cultural and political background, achieving their objectives became strenuous (Naval War College, U.S., 2002). One of Bremer’s advisors failed to critically analyze the Iraqi political environment. Critical analysis is important since it enhances intellectual skills that are necessary in confronting the obstacles involved in the provision of effective staff. This analysis also plays a vital role in decision support on the crucial decision-making process about policy implementation. Ambassador Horan, an advisor to Bremer dismissed Sistani as ‘shaggy fellows’ and referred to them as detached from current on goings. Another reason as to why the CPA failed was because of the assumption that profane former exiles supported by the American government would back the plan. The isolation of US political officials also made it difficult for them to understand the influence of the statute immediately. The drawback of the pre-invasion assumptions that the CPA had concerning the probable role religion would play in Iraq was based on undependable information. The US government also failed to consider the moderation of the Shia community (Naval War College, U.S., 2002). One socio-economic challenge that made the American plan fail was the lack of proper information about the Shiite religious hierarchy. Attempts to persuade other ayatollahs to go against Sistani proved futile. When this failed, they decided to turn to politicians. This was however also unsuccessful because of the assumption that the Shiite politicians had the ability to influence Sistani to annul his fatwa. They were also under the impression that if Sistani’s persistence continued, the politicians would cross him on the argument that religion must not interfere with politics. It was soon evident that the politicians wished for the blessing of the high-ranking ayatollah as well as his seal of approval. They were therefore in support of his views about the clergy and his right to provide guidance and counseling to political leaders (Naval War College, U.S., 2002). Eventually, the CPA staff also succumbed to the unavoidable and commenced indirect consultations with Sistani about the TAL. In spite of Bremer’s insisting on the installation of the entire array of western liberal rights, the TAL cited religious laws of the Muslims as a legislation source. It also included the provision that no law should go against the primary code of belief of Islam. U. S officials also the tendency to interpret Sistani’s remarks as what they wanted to hear. They made efforts to project their views on the grand ayatollah. The complication in communication between the ayatollah and CPA was the language barrier combined with cultural concerns. It was also not always distinct if Bremer’s messages really got to Sistani through the mediators or if they were even able to mend the folk gap between the two protagonists. An additional concern was that a few of the envois had very little interest in ensuring preciseness in communications. They seemed to be more interested in enhancing their own reputations. Bremer’s plans for political change in Iraq seemed to be running a ground. The only true contact he had was in May 2003 through Sergio Vieira de Mello, the special representative of the United Nations Secretary-General for Iraq. De Mello however died in the August 2003 terrorist attack against the UN mission. Situational awareness is an imperative when it comes to policy implementation in a foreign nation. Most of the members of the Coalition Provisional Authority lacked sufficient knowledge about the Iraqi politics and society. A surprisingly low number of them spoke Arabic hence the few local connoisseurs on board. This only meant that the association was very much unaware of the hazwa or its organization and were hence unable to conjure easier interactions with the Shia clerics. The strategy of separation of politics and religion failed since CPA lost all control of the process. Bremer’s lack of acknowledgement of the great ayatollah was his major flaw. He only realized this at the end of his term in his administrative role in the CPA. By this time it was too late for the CPA to retrace their steps and was forced to forfeit their plans. For successful leadership, one needs to regularly evaluate their organization and analyze such questions as; are goals being reached and mission accomplished? Is the team properly geared up for obstacles in future? Etc. To effectively answer these questions, Bremer and his staff should have come up with a technique of comprehensively and thoughtfully assessing their situation. References Top of Form Naval War Coll Newport Ri, Alvi, Hayat, & Gvosdev, Nikolas K. (2010). Case Studies in Policy Making. Twelfth Edition. Bottom of Form Top of Form Naval War College (U.S.). (2002). Newport papers: National security strategy after 9/11/01. Newport, RI: Naval War College. Bottom of Form Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ayatollah versus the Ambassador: The Influence Case Study”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/military/1628879-ayatollah-versus-the-ambassador-the-influence
(Ayatollah Versus the Ambassador: The Influence Case Study)
https://studentshare.org/military/1628879-ayatollah-versus-the-ambassador-the-influence.
“Ayatollah Versus the Ambassador: The Influence Case Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/military/1628879-ayatollah-versus-the-ambassador-the-influence.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ayatollah versus the Ambassador: The Influence of Religion on Politics in Post-Saddam Iraq

The Iran-Iraq War of the 1980s

The revolution in Iran also marked the first time that clerics of Islam had harnessed the authority of religion to overthrow a modern and secular state with a theocracy (Jacek 39).... The origin of Iran-iraq War The Iran-iraq war began in 1980 and lasted for approximately 8 years.... The origin of Iran-iraq War The Iran-iraq war began in 1980 and lasted for approximately 8 years.... Various factors relating to the regime changes in both countries led to a full-blown war between iraq and Iran, and a proxy war between Iran & the US....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Shiite Festivals in Iran and Iraq

This essay "Shiite Festivals in Iran and iraq" is about Shiites or Shi'a which is one of the two major denominations of Islam.... Although the Shiites were considered a minority in most of the Islamic world, they were the majority in countries like Iran and iraq.... The other holy site located in iraq in Najaf.... Shiites in iraq comprised sixty percent of the Iraqi population but were the most oppressed and marginalized during the regime of Saddam Hussein....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Iran During the Rule of Ayatollah Khomeini

But mostly he lived in Nazaf of iraq which was under Saddam Hussein's power, then Turkey and France.... rg] Protest grew against the rule of Shah which gave more influence to Khomeini.... This essay "Iran During the Rule of ayatollah Khomeini" focuses on ayatollah Ruhullah Musawi who came into this world on 21 September 1902 through Ayatullah Sayid Mustafa Musawi and Hajiyah Aga Khanam in the town of Khomein, South of the capital Tehran, Iran....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Politics and Religion: the Islamic Republic of Iran

Politics and Religion: Case of the Islamic Republic of IranWhat is the role of religion, particularly Islam, in modern Islamic republics?... The Iran-iraq war empowered the 'populist' Islamic authority to mobilize the masses and suppress opponents under the flag of defending Islam.... Had Iran's war with iraq (1981-1988) did not take place, Alamdari argued that Islamic populism could have ended more quickly after the 1979 Islamic Iranian revolution (Alamdari, 2005, p....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Arab Politics -The Baath Party

Because Arab politics is mostly connected with religion and there is no existence for politics in Arab countries without religion.... It has attained international fame because of its association with former iraq president Saddam Husain.... Though Baath party has extended its roots to many Arab countries like Syria, Egypt, iraq, Jordan etc as a symbol of Arab unity, it didn't survive long because of its composition of different political regimes and originThe Arab Socialist Baath Party was founded in Syria in the 1940s by a small group of French-educated Syrian intellectuals - Michel Aflaq, a Greek Orthodox, and Salah al-Din al-Bitar, a Sunni Muslim....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Muslim Political Interests: Winning Special Privileges for Islam

The paper "Muslim Political Interests: Winning Special Privileges for Islam" presents Muslim immigrants of recent years.... South Asians appear to be the best educated of all.... This impressive fact results in part from the Muslim community in North America drawing disproportionately on the elites....
56 Pages (14000 words) Essay

The Rise and Fall of Saddam Hussein

This paper focuses on the rise and fall of Saddam Hussein who was a former president of iraq.... Saddam Hussein has been described as 'the Victorious Leader, Glory of the Arabs, Grandson of the Prophet Mohamed, Lion of iraq, Successor of Nebuchadnezzar and the New Saladin' during his zenith.... Saddam Hussein was born in 1937 to an underprivileged peasant family near Takrit in the heart of iraq.... In 'Saddam Hussein of iraq: A Political Psychology Profile,' Post examines the psychological profile of Hussein and argues that this labeling is 'pejorative' and 'inaccurate' (279)....
28 Pages (7000 words) Research Paper

War in Iraq over Religion

"War in iraq over Religion" paper states that several efforts have been to reconcile the two sects of Islam but the uprising and consequent civil war in Syria has crippled these efforts because it's believed that Iranian weapons, monies and Shiite fighters have been slaughtering its Sunni population.... n iraq the Shia are said to be the majority by 65% while the Sunnis are about 32%, interestingly the Sunnis are further split into ethnic groups majorly the Kurds, Turkmen, and Arabs (Denton-Borhaug, 2012)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us