StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The discussion of Nagel Thomases Death - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Thomas Nagel dissects the argument of death being a bad thing or not and comes up with a variety of examples to prove his case. His whole article balances the two arguments, on one hand, death is seen as dreadful because it takes all we have and makes it unbearable to lose it…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.5% of users find it useful
The discussion of Nagel Thomases Death
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The discussion of Nagel Thomases Death"

Nagel, Thomas, “Death”, from Mortal Questions, Cambridge Press, 1979. Section Thomas Nagel dissects the argument of death being a bad thing or not and comes up with a variety of examples to prove his case. His whole article balances the two arguments, on one hand, death is seen as dreadful because it takes all we have and makes it unbearable to lose it. On the other hand, if one perceives death as not responsible for the loss, but as a mere blank that happens in a person’s existence, then it will be seen as something that has little or no value.

Death can be a subjective concept. It depends on the context when and why it happened. For example, in comparing the perception of death of a young person and the death of an old person, one can easily point out that the death of the younger person is more of a loss because he still has his whole life ahead of him. The older person’s death does not make it better to the people he leaves behind, but at least he has had more time and chances to make his life worth living. Another context is if the person has seen his life as good, then death is perceived to take away that goodness and so, it is viewed as evil, and dreadful.

But for those whose lives do not seem to have anything good to offer, then they may even look forward to death claiming them so as to end their misery. Nagel raised three problems with regards to death. The first is if there could be anything that can be bad for a person without him knowing about it. If death comes at a time that is unexpected, then the dead person is unaware that he is dead, so could that be considered bad? Another problem is the understanding of existence. Simply put, if a person is still alive, he exists, and if he has died, then he no longer exists, so this premise seems to point no time when death can be blamed for such a misfortune, if it is indeed seen as a misfortune.

The last problem is related to the previous two. In case of non-existence before one is born and after one has died, how can one view death and non-existence after one has lived as bad while the non-existence before life as not? Nagel argues that perceptions of misfortune and death depend on time. If a person has been doing very well in his life and is suddenly struck with a fatal accident that leaves him as helpless as an infant, then it is considered a tragedy by his family, friends and society in general.

This is not the same for the infant who has not achieved anything else in his life except to be born alive and to grow into the infant he is now. Simultaneously, for the individual himself, he does not seem to care what has happened to him as long as he is kept comfortable physically. This can be paralleled to death. The corpse of the person may be left to rot naturally but the individual’s loss is grieved by people around him. The loss is actually felt by those he left behind and not by him.

The mentally ill may also be clueless as to his own existence, but the people around him mourn the death of his potentials to be a highly functioning person. If a person’s life has got everything good going for him then death would really be seen as a culprit that would end the good fortune one is amassing even if death is viewed as a natural part of life. If one sees as everything in life as good, then he is bound to see the end (death) in a bad way. Section 2 Nagel’s arguments about death seem to be logical and agreeable to me.

He takes on an objective and detached approach towards death that it is so easy to draw the line between existence and non-existence when death claims a life. He is right in saying that death is viewed as unfortunate if one sees his own life as worth living, no matter what his experiences are, but death is seen as something irrelevant if one just lives for the sake of existing. If death comes, it is not a big deal. Although I agree with Nagel’s premises, I am not as detached as he is, and not as easily convinced by logic that death merely ceases one’s existence.

Anyone’s death is considered a loss to his or her family, and calls for other people’s sympathy and empathy. People may mourn the loss of opportunities for the dead person, and may feel their regrets that he or she may have amounted to something more had death not claimed him or her. No matter how unsuccessful the person who died may have been, no matter how much death relieves him of life’s stresses, it is still considered a loss to the people he leaves behind. No longer will he be seen alive, with them, and perhaps, making an effort to make his life better than it is.

He is deprived of chances in improving his lot. How much more if the deceased person has lived a very fulfilling life? His accomplishments are celebrated, and his legacy lives on, but he is already gone to reap the glory. That would likewise be a pity! Ideally, one is given the honor he deserves while he is living rather than posthumous, although the family would still appreciate such honor bestowed upon their beloved departed. So, as much as I agree with Nagel’s well-argued points about death and misfortune, I still believe that it should be given more weight in terms of the human experience.

It creates a great impact in the lives of those the deceased has left behind. He or she may cease to exist, as Nagel premises, however, it is the memory he or she leaves behind that may inspire, enliven and empower the people who would cherish them. This way, the death gives way to more life.

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The discussion of Nagel Thomases Death Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
The discussion of Nagel Thomases Death Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1467351-the-discussion-of-nagel-thomases-death
(The Discussion of Nagel Thomases Death Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
The Discussion of Nagel Thomases Death Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1467351-the-discussion-of-nagel-thomases-death.
“The Discussion of Nagel Thomases Death Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1467351-the-discussion-of-nagel-thomases-death.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The discussion of Nagel Thomases Death

Thomas Hardy's Tess of the D'Urbervilles and George Eliot's Adam Bede

This study takes a look at how the class divide and death have an effect on the story and the characters by comparing the way in which these motifs have been used by the writers.... Tess of the D'Urbervilles and Adam Bede are two of the most important works published in the 19th century....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Are Neuroscientists Able to Explain Human Consciousness

The essay talks about the facts we've already known about the human consciousness.... The paper also analyzes if the scientists are able to explain the human consciousness in terms of modern neuroscience and not with philosophical debate or qualitative psychological descriptions.... hellip; As whatever consciousness ultimately might be, it is somehow based on the workings of the central nervous system....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Death and the Meaning of Life

As the discussion declares the obvious hole in this line of reasoning is the idea that the soul might be able to detach itself from the body and continue to exist, regardless of its exact form and nature.... This essay asks and answers the question what are death and the meaning of life?... Given that the above two premises are accepted as fact, Nagel says without meaning after death and without meaning during life, there can be no meaning to life....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Life of Jesus and Mohammed

A large amount of debate and discussion has been the prominent feature of literature related to the Prophet Mohammed's life from the beginning.... In this topic, we study the lives of Jesus Christ and Mohammed, the two highly worshipped souls by two different religions namely Christianity and Islam, respectively....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Speech of Elizabeth Costello about Unethical Behaviour of Humans with the Animals

The writer of the essay "Elizabeth Costello" suggests that Costello presents to the whole audience some facts; based on her intellectual observation and these not only relate the tortures man does on animals but also those he commits as a group, totally unaware of what they're doing.... … Here Costello expresses her disgust regarding the butcher farms, frozen food (meat) and of course the readymade brands; all of which have drastically changed the concepts about an animal and have led us to believe that these products are nothing but for nurturing ourselves, ‘and isn't this all what it's about?...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Thomas Nagel, death

death is a complex aspect that has to There are a number of arguments that have been presented in the written work by Nagel concerning the death being an ultimate loss.... However, the major aspect that has been well evaluated by the author through rhetoric is the understanding of death being an ultimate loss or the perfect end of an existence.... Herein, one can notice that there is strength as well as weakness of the claim concerning death in the written piece....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Analysis on Humans and Animals

Following the idea expressed by Costello, who is an imaginative character of the novelist from the book by John Coetzee, we'll develop her idea basing on works by Locke, Wallace, and nagel.... Thomas nagel in his article “What is like to be a bat?... nagel underlines that consciousness is presented in animals as well as in humans.... In accordance with the scientist, bats are closely related to humans (nagel, p45)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Thomas Hardy's Tess of the D'Urbervilles and George Eliot's Adam Bede

Though both these works are very different in many literary aspects, there are also certain similarities because of the… This study takes a look at how the class divide and death have an effect on the story and the characters by comparing the way in which these motifs have been used by the writers. The social class and level of poverty are two The writer, Thomas Hardy lived in an era when England was facing a deep social crisis after the onset of the industrial revolution....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us