StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

IS CPHL214 A PHILOSOPHY COURSE OR WHAT - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
At places it makes suppositions and claims that are not warranted or backed by facts. The first paragraphs are fairly coherent and logically consistent, excepting for the last two lines. It says,…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.5% of users find it useful
IS CPHL214 A PHILOSOPHY COURSE OR WHAT
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "IS CPHL214 A PHILOSOPHY COURSE OR WHAT"

Critical Response to IS CPHL214 A PHILOSOPHY OR WHAT? The passage to be critiqued has its fair share of logical flaws and fallacies. At places it makes suppositions and claims that are not warranted or backed by facts. The first paragraphs are fairly coherent and logically consistent, excepting for the last two lines. It says, “Everybody knows that philosophy is of no practical use. Since its not of any practical use, it must be a philosophy course”. This is a logical error, for philosophy is not the only thing that is of no practical use.

Whether or not the course is of any practical use can be one of many indicators to decide if it a philosophy course, but only the only indicator. In the second paragraph, unsubstantiated attributions are made to the professor. While the professor might have said “critical thinking skills are good things to have”, he did not seemed to have said that “its good to be picky, argumentative, always finding something wrong with whatever students write, and cynical”. The latter is merely an interpretation on part of the writer as to what the professor meant by his comment.

This interpretation comes across as exaggerated and negatively biased against the professor. Moreover, while there is a link between critical thinking courses and the broader philosophy courses, whether or not the courses are “good” is an irrelevant deviation from the argument. The last two lines of the second paragraph are also display an error in syllogism. It doesn’t stand to reason that all critical thinking courses are philosophy courses, just because this claim cannot be proven false.

In the third paragraph, the perusal of hear-say evidence of Bertha weakens the argument. Moreover, Bertha’s friends don’t represent the entire student population, in order that sweeping conclusions could be made based on the evidence provided by her. That Bertha’s friends’ course did and CPHL214 did not talk about the “meaning of life” doesn’t make the two courses incompatible – they could just be two variations of a common theme.In the fourth paragraph the assertion that “meaning of life is interesting” appears arbitrary, unsubstantiated as it is with any rationale.

Likewise, “there’s no way CPHL214 is interesting” is also a subjective judgment and not an indisputable fact. Defining philosophy as the “study of human life” is too simplistic and vague for the purposes of classifying CPHL214.Coming to the fifth paragraph the fact that the professor works for money and that he has a stake in the functioning of the philosophy department doesn’t make him a liar. Once again, the relation between philosophy professors, eccentric behavior and false claims is an error in deductive logic and syllogism.

The final paragraph, the assertion that philosophy professors are “worthy of imitation” is arbitrary and subjective. And the concluding words “you would want to spend all your time criticizing” is tangential to the main concern of the write-up, namely, “Is CPHL214 a Philosophy course?”

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“IS CPHL214 A PHILOSOPHY COURSE OR WHAT Assignment”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1599577-is-cphl214-a-philosophy-course-or-what
(IS CPHL214 A PHILOSOPHY COURSE OR WHAT Assignment)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1599577-is-cphl214-a-philosophy-course-or-what.
“IS CPHL214 A PHILOSOPHY COURSE OR WHAT Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1599577-is-cphl214-a-philosophy-course-or-what.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF IS CPHL214 A PHILOSOPHY COURSE OR WHAT

Companion to Wittgensteins Tractatus

The basic metaphysical problems of logical form or representations is a central and general problem in Wittgestein related to what Max Black refers as ‘transempirical' concepts.... he possibility of the program itself, that is, the general program which is what constitutes the context of the picture theory of meaning is ascribe and ascertain a "totality of facts".... Further, his concern resembles more of a possible world than an actual world in this regard, and one might phrase this program in the following way: supposing one wanted to exhaust the possibilities of truth, what type of formal system along with its....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Approaches to Antiquity

The person gives utmost value to what is inside him rather than what is outside him.... It has the freewill to decide its course of action but results are connected to its fate and predestined factors of his previous and present lives.... But in the course of life time, due to certain depression on frustration, one tends to take support of other identities to find joy and pleasure.... Topic : philosophy Text Heading - Approaches to Self and Person in Antiquity(Summary) In this part of the text the author mentions that definitely there is something called self and it can be collectively aimed at the owner of the body as well as the psychological feeling we undergo in ourselves....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Concealment and Exposure

what do we think about for our comfort?... This what those religious practices teaches Christian's to trust so that they can overcome difficulties in their life and find comfort for a meaningful life.... The main purpose of the questions people have every day in their life is to get the information and the real background why things happen like that, and what can we do to understand them.... what does it mean when the sky above is blue but there is a dark line all the way around the horizon?...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Major Philosophical Issues

Velasquez has maintained that various philosophers like Bantham had pursued the philosophy that actions, which result in maximum happiness for maximum number of people, are invariable good and therefore, the end justifies the means if it generates happiness for people.... Velasquez has preferred the moderated version of Kantian philosophy and believes that people must act in the manner that minimizes harm and promotes happiness amongst maximum number of people....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Relationship between Dreams and Reality in Light of Descartes Views

The latter especially raises the issue of delusion and questioning what is e worry that this world might too be a dream was famously expressed by the French philosopher Rene Descartes in the seventeenth century in his Meditations.... After pointing out what happens during sleep, he makes his ‘dreaming argument' when he writes, “In dwelling carefully on this reflection, I see so manifestly that there are no certain indications by which we may clearly distinguish wakefulness from sleep that I am lost in astonishment....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Nature of Reality

When a person realizes what he/she truly need in this life and tries to achieve his/her goal in this life, such a life direction would make a person happy.... Meaning of life is what we live for.... He based his explanation of the nature of reality on Teacher's 9 October philosophy Reality is everything which can be observed or comprehended through our senses.... Existence of God is rather contradictory issue in philosophy.... However, there are some philosophers such as Thomas Aquinas, whose philosophy is tightly connected with the idea of God....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

What Is Philosophy

In addition, philosophy mainly refers to basic principles and ideas in life that guides individuals in Philosophy what is philosophy?... Refer to at least five philosophers we have studied in the course of your answer.... philosophy is an academic discipline that uses reasons and logic in an effort to understand reality besides believing in certain aspects (Lawhead 37).... philosophy is an academic discipline that uses reasons and logic in an effort to understand reality besides believing in certain aspects (Lawhead 37)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Philosophy: The Concept of Utilitarism

According to the utilitarism morality is based upon the common good (happiness for most people) which Bentham called the common benefit, of course, distinguishing it from self-interest, or personal benefit.... But it forms only one part in the big world of philosophy and science....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us