StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Choose an argument from the readings and explain it in your own words - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The identity of an individual lies in their consciousness. He writes that the identity of man is like that of other animals in one fitly…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.1% of users find it useful
Choose an argument from the readings and explain it in your own words
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Choose an argument from the readings and explain it in your own words"

Philosophy In this ‘of diversity and personality essay,’ John Locke argues that the identity of man is tied to various aspects of body and shape. The identity of an individual lies in their consciousness. He writes that the identity of man is like that of other animals in one fitly organized body (Locke 277). He appears to conclude from this that the identity of man consists of a participation of the same continued life and united to the one organized body. Roughly, the idea underlying the first premise is that an individual is often defined as thinking individual and thought can never be separated from consciousness.

By consciousness, Locke means that individuals are able to be aware or perceive something. So, the first premise says that consciousness is independent of any other substances. This does not, however, claim that consciousness is able to exist without a body or a mind. Assuming that consciousness is tied to a given body or soul is not necessary. In this sense though, there is still no reason to make the assumption that consciousness is not transferable from one body or even mind to the next.

The second premise means just that a person’s identity is separate from any form of immaterial substance. After all, an individual’s consciousness is connected to their thought, and their mind is their thinking thing. Consciousness, despite Locke insisting, is not connected to a mind even if it needs some mind or other. This raises some problems considering that must either be a substance or even a quality of a certain substance. Considering that Locke explains that consciousness has cannot exist on its own, and it must be a part of some mind, then it appears that consciousness is a property belonging to the minds.

It is not clear if a property is transferable from one substance to the next. On this matter, Locke writes that if the soul identity makes the same man, then there is no reason as to why similar spirits of an individual may be overly united to various bodies (Locke 278). The third premise might reasonably be taken to mean consciousness is independent of any other substance or that person’s identity is separate from any form of immaterial substance. But given that Locke writes that there is nothing in the matter why an individual spirit is united to various bodies, it is clear that he means that an individual person’s identity is different from their immaterial substance (Locke 279).

Thus, since the argument is valid, the conclusion necessary follows from the premises. It is true according to Locke that consciousness is independent of any other substances. However, it is also evident from other Locke’s arguments that a person’s argument is separate from their immaterial substance. This acts as a contradiction considering that an individual’s consciousness is connected to their thoughts. Thus, despite Locke insisting, an individual’s consciousness is not connected to the mind.

The mind only acts as their thinking. Thus, identity of an individual must exist only in their consciousness and nothing else.Works CitedLocke, John. Of Identity and diversity. New York : Routledge, 1812.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Choose an argument from the readings and explain it in your own words Assignment - 2”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1687472-choose-an-argument-from-the-readings-and-explain-it-in-your-own-words
(Choose an Argument from the Readings and Explain It in Your Own Words Assignment - 2)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1687472-choose-an-argument-from-the-readings-and-explain-it-in-your-own-words.
“Choose an Argument from the Readings and Explain It in Your Own Words Assignment - 2”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1687472-choose-an-argument-from-the-readings-and-explain-it-in-your-own-words.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Choose an argument from the readings and explain it in your own words

Schizophrenia: The Divided Self by RD Laing

Rather, a humane and concentrated focused (keeping your own voice down so that you can hear what others have to say) attitude is very much essential as well as necessary in order to understand the patient from every aspect.... A very nice way of summarizing the arguments is a very simple sentence taken from the book (page 33):"If we look... Existential phenomenology is what gives meaning of ones own self and the world in which that individual lives, and dwells....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

What if Toward Excellence in Reasoning by Hintikka & Bachman

rdquo; Explanations: These lines explain that it is not only entertainment, which is sought out by the masses.... This paper is being carried out to evaluate and present the taken from “What if…?... The argument analyses of the given passage are as under Statement: “If you want an explanation for declining literacy rates in the U.... rdquo; (Final Conclusion) Explanations: These lines disclose the conclusion of the argument, where the writers have refuted the idea that television has led to low literacy rate....
6 Pages (1500 words) Thesis Proposal

Guarding Your Handprints

The main focus of the paper "Guarding your Handprints" is on the ability of a dream to look like a reality, a real-life situation, capacity for reflection on one's current state, the function of the hands, biopsychology, neural communication, a subconscious part of our mind?... Because we are not dreaming for few minutes like we remember when we wake up from a dream, we cannot really prove if we woke up from real life and continuing to dream or woke up from a dream and continuing the real life....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Clothing is Not Superficial Argumentation

So, what is the truth behind Miller's argument that clothing is not superficial?... Considering all these questions, the next part of this paper will focus on discussing the extent to which I have agreed with Miller's argument on clothing and its representation to the inner and physical self.... Therefore, to be able to clearly understand Miller's argument, one has to go beyond what normal eyes can see....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Cultural Industry as a Part of the Capitalist Society and Fiskes Argument

He then goes on to declare that 'with very few and very marginal exceptions, people cannot and do not produce their own commodities'.... om, to create and diffuse their own cultural commodities like never before.... The paper describes Fiske's argument that is no doubt sound as far as his analysis of the functioning of a capitalist economy is concerned and certainly, given the constant lamentation of parents' groups over Pepsi sponsored sports stadiums and the like, this development is unmistakeably in evidence....
10 Pages (2500 words) Literature review

Analysis of The Apple Argument Against Abortion Article by Peter Kreeft

The author tries to explain all those issues in a simple, but comprehensive manner so that anybody who decides to perform abortion may think twice or thrice before doing so, after reading this article.... He has started his teaching career from Villanova University from 1962-1965 and later joined Boston College as a professor.... Apart from many articles, he has written many books such as The Snakebite Letters, The Philosophy of Jesus, The Journey: A Spiritual Roadmap for Modern Pilgrims, Prayer: The Great Conversation: Straight Answers to Tough Questions About Prayer, etc....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Chapter 9 of Norton Psychology

hellip; from the two texts analyzed, it is easier to see how weak the mind and memory are in terms of storing information.... They found that the patient wrote down more words than expected from the study list but did not recall seeing those words before.... Another flaw that I see from the findings of Schacter is that when trying to prove a point there is no counterargument that can explain why people without amnesia or a head injury recall memories without effort....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Analyzing a Student Text: How to Be Fit and Healthy Written by Roland

Eating the right amount of food serves but without the exercise would be unbalancing for your body.... Last but not least, having a good night's sleep helps to get through your next day.... In the following, I will explain the best ways to look after yourselves and be fit and healthy.... A bad night's sleep gives you no habitat and tiredness which refrains you from working out or participating in sports....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us